You can also contact Kathy Holmes at kholmes@cullmanswcd.com or 256-734-1431. And the recent news has shown us that it definitely could have went a different way. From The New York Times, Im Michael Barbaro. CULLMAN, Ala. - Below are the arrests and incidents reported Aug. 27, 2020. Right? And the guy comes up with, like, a white sheet of paper. Access details about a criminal complaint by calling the Sheriff's Office at 256-734-0342. Entries for each day are listed alphabetically by surname. They wonder whether they need to put their daughters into therapy. She started wanting to play cops and robbers. The Detroit Police Department should stop using facial recognition technology as an investigatory tool, Mr. Mayor wrote in the complaint, adding, as the facts of Mr. Williamss case prove both that the technology is flawed and that DPD investigators are not competent in making use of such technology.. 157; gas; $9, third-degree assault; person; Pine Hill Dr. NW, third-degree theft of property; person; Katherine St. NW; phone; $600, third-degree criminal mischief; Cullman City Park & Rec. He waited outside in the rain for 30 minutes until his wife could pick him up. Education, community, local government focus of annual State of Our Communities PREP SOFTBALL: Lady Aggies hammer Guntersville on the road 17-2; Fairview,, Cold Springs Elementary set to host Life is Art 5K Fun, Sacred Heart of Jesus Church hosts 1st Birmingham Diocesan Day of. Arrests and incidents reported Aug. 24, 2020, PREP SOFTBALL: Lady Aggies hammer Guntersville on the road 17-2; Fairview, Vinemont collect county wins, PREP SOFTBALL: Addison drops Tuesday night battle with Lynn 15-3, PREP BASEBALL: Bearcats fall to Vestavia Hills 6-3, PREP BASEBALL: Addison handles Winston County 16-0, CCBOE names AmFirst Teacher, Staff Member of the Month, Alabama Robotics Technology Park comes to Cullman City Schools, Cold Springs Elementary set to host Life is Art 5K Fun Run & Walk Saturday, COLUMN: The spiritual recommitment of Lent, Were just saturating the place with prayer, Sacred Heart of Jesus Church hosts 1st Birmingham Diocesan Day of Liturgical Formation, St. Bernard opens school with service of commitment and blessing, ADCNR strengthens safeguards against nonnative species, Letter to the Editor: In support of Colony Mayor Donnis Leeth. Google it, she recalls an officer replying. Just because their technology wrongfully identified this man, he gets more closely watched by the police without his knowledge. The system would have mapped the mans face and searched for similar ones in a collection of 49 million photos. April 12, 2021. Do the personal hygiene . And theyre like, what you in here for? The Detroit Police Department said this was a horrible investigation. Mr. Williams asked if he was free to go. When you complete such registration you will receive access to a third party membership area - of which the owners of this website have no control of. Like, just bring it up out of nowhere, like, oh yeah, in case anyone mentioned it, he was arrested, but he didnt do anything. PREP SOFTBALL: Lady Aggies hammer Guntersville on the road 17-2; Fairview, unlawful possession of marijuana; unlawful possession of drug paraphernalia; Hwy. The office is located at 1910 Beech Avenue Southeast, Cullman, AL 35055. 157; general merchandise; $18, fourth-degree theft of property; Wal-Mart; Olive St. SW; general merchandise; $351, fourth-degree theft of property; The Foundry; 2nd Ave. SW; miscellaneous, third-degree criminal trespassing; Comfort Suites; St. Joseph Drive NW, unlawful breaking and entering of a motor vehicle; person; Northwest Lane NW; cash, FTA- fourth-degree theft of property (2 counts), FTA- second-degree unlawful possession of marijuana, unlawful possession or receipt of a controlled substance. I got arrested. Five timepieces, worth $3,800, were shoplifted. And they have three pieces of paper face down in front of them. Copyright 2011-document.write(new Date().getFullYear()) alabamaarrests.org. And Im like, computer got it wrong? 157; food, cash; $31, fourth-degree theft of property; Wal-Mart; Hwy. 157; pool; $444, third-degree theft of property; fraudulent use of credit/debit card; person; miscellaneous charges, fourth-degree theft of property; third-degree criminal trespass; Wal-Mart; Hwy. All records presented on this site are gathered from third party databases that are not controlled by the owners of this site. CULLMAN, Ala. Below are the arrests and incidents reported Sept. 3, 2020. Get information on arrests and jail records by calling the Cullman County Detention Center at 256-735-2400. All persons are innocent until proven guilty. But when he went to the hearing, the prosecutor decided to drop the case. He was driving home from work, and a song came on the radio that his mother loved: the song We Are One by Maze and Frankie Beverly. He picked up the image and held it next to his face. 157; ornaments, toys, miscellaneous; $389, fourth-degree theft of property; Wal-Mart; Olive St. SW; alcohol; $76, third-degree domestic violence- harassing communications; person, second-degree criminal mischief; The Sport Center; 2nd Ave. SW; damaged window; $700, fourth-degree theft of property; Wal-Mart; Hwy. Founded in South Carolina in 2000, the company first offered mug shot management software, said Todd Pastorini, a general manager. So Robert had to hire a lawyer to defend himself. They want to have more, what you call false positives, because they want to have the greatest pool of possible suspects that they can, because they want to find the bad guy. GJ = grand jury; FTA = failure to appear Cullman County Sheriff's Office. The website owners receive compensation if you complete a registration through our website. Rank Ones chief executive, Brendan Klare, said the company had developed a new algorithm for NIST to review that tightens the differences in accuracy between different demographic cohorts., After Ms. Coulson, of the state police, ran her search of the probe image, the system would have provided a row of results generated by NEC and a row from Rank One, along with confidence scores. In Mr. Williamss recollection, after he held the surveillance video still next to his face, the two detectives leaned back in their chairs and looked at one another. So I just kept telling her that they made a mistake. You know, its not something that easily rolls off the tongue, like, oh yeah, and guess what? When they pulled up to our house, they were already combative on the phone. This is just the first time we know about it.. So back in this room, the two detectives now have the real Robert Williams in front of them. A few years ago, an M.I.T. And I said, I just got a really weird call. Education, community, local government focus of annual State of Our Communities PREP SOFTBALL: Lady Aggies hammer Guntersville on the road 17-2; Fairview,, Cold Springs Elementary set to host Life is Art 5K Fun, Sacred Heart of Jesus Church hosts 1st Birmingham Diocesan Day of. And I was like, what are you doing up? About Mr. Williamss experience in Michigan, she added: I strongly suspect this is not the first case to misidentify someone to arrest them for a crime they didnt commit. And DataWorks Plus contracts out to two other companies called N.E.C. Well, the computer got it wrong is what threw me off. Find arrest reports online Monday-Friday at www.CullmanTribune.com. So youre saying the facial recognition algorithm basically created a lineup of potential suspects. Of course, I answered the other line. 278 E. unlawful possession of drug paraphernalia; domestic violence; Colony Rd. August 16, 2021. Shes picking up her daughter. But they dropped it without prejudice, which meant that they could charge him again. Yeah. And there is no standardized testing. So why is this officer calling her? Jerry Wayne Eddleman, 81, of Cullman, died peacefully at home on Feb. 18, 2023, surrounded by his family. Its a Thursday afternoon in Farmington Hills, Michigan, which is just outside of Detroit. So he had a perfect attendance at work until that day that he was arrested. https://www.nytimes.com/2020/06/24/technology/facial-recognition-arrest.html, This is not me, Robert Julian-Borchak Williams told investigators. It was almost that it was too accurate, that it knew too much. Incidents. They have a $200 proposal, which does not meet the needs of Americas working families. Like, identifying a really clear photo is a lot easier than identifying surveillance footage. GJ = grand jury; FTA. And theyll use any clue they can to do it, including facial recognition. His wife, Melissa, asked where he was being taken. And even when we know something is flawed, if its a computer telling us to do it, we just think its right. By: Cullman Tribune Staff. CULLMAN, Ala. Below are the arrests and incidents reported Aug. 27, 2020. GJ = grand jury; FTA = failure to appear. So Im like, well, I cant turn myself in then. They dont know how to de-escalate a situation.. When the case was called, the prosecutor moved to dismiss, but without prejudice, meaning Mr. Williams could later be charged again. So they ran a search on this, what they call a probe image, this picture for the surveillance video, which is really grainy. You think all Black men look alike?CreditSylvia Jarrus for The New York Times. The police wouldnt say why he was being arrested, only showing him a piece of paper with his photo and the words felony warrant and larceny.. Its not a very good photo. They basically had to tell him that they used facial recognition, you know, to put him there. He was there for a few minutes. So I get out of the car. You know, they sat back and looked at each other and was like, with the oops face, right? He was driving home from work, and had posted a video to his private Instagram because a song he loved came on 1983s We Are One, by Maze and Frankie Beverly. Arrests and incidents reported Aug. 27, 2020, PREP SOFTBALL: Lady Aggies hammer Guntersville on the road 17-2; Fairview, Vinemont collect county wins, PREP SOFTBALL: Addison drops Tuesday night battle with Lynn 15-3, PREP BASEBALL: Bearcats fall to Vestavia Hills 6-3, PREP BASEBALL: Addison handles Winston County 16-0, CCBOE names AmFirst Teacher, Staff Member of the Month, Alabama Robotics Technology Park comes to Cullman City Schools, Cold Springs Elementary set to host Life is Art 5K Fun Run & Walk Saturday, COLUMN: The spiritual recommitment of Lent, Were just saturating the place with prayer, Sacred Heart of Jesus Church hosts 1st Birmingham Diocesan Day of Liturgical Formation, St. Bernard opens school with service of commitment and blessing, Troy University renames building after Congressman John Lewis, LP Building Solutions awards scholarships to 3 local students. Federal unemployment benefits have expired for tens of millions of Americans after Congress failed to reach a deal to renew them last week. So one thing the Detroit Police Department said was, well, this was a case that predates this new policy we have that says, you know, were only supposed to be using facial recognition for violent crimes. It sounds thin all the way around, he said. and says, do all Black men look the same to you? Basically, find other evidence that this person is the person that committed the crime. And some dont work well. These included 235 burglaries, and 553 larceny-thefts that were reported as property offenses. And she would always pretend like he was the robber who stole something, and she would need to lock him up in the living room. We apologize, the prosecutor, Kym L. Worthy, said in a statement, adding, This does not in any way make up for the hours that Mr. Williams spent in jail.. Probable cause is the belief that the suspect probably committed the alleged crime based upon the facts submitted to the court. Information found on this site must be used for lawfully acceptable purposes only. So Robert picks the piece of paper up, holds it next to his own face . CULLMAN, Ala. - Below are the arrests and incidents reported Feb. 27, 2023. Right. Oh yeah. So when we talk about facial recognition, we often think of it as a monolith, that theres kind of one facial recognition. But in fact, theres a bunch of different companies that all have their own algorithms. Information that can be found on this site is compiled from records that may be incomplete or have errors. NE, FTA- third-degree criminal trespass (2 counts), unlawful possession/receiving controlled substance, second-degree unlawful possession of marijuana. And we werent sure, did she tell her teacher? The large majority of crimes were related to property; however, approximately 815 violent crimes were committed during that time. CULLMAN, Ala. - Below are the arrests and incidents reported Aug. 24, 2020. So this was an admission by the detectives that it was a computer that had pointed the finger at Robert Williams. This isnt how its supposed to work. And they said that Robert Williams would have his information expunged from the system his mug shot, his DNA. In Cullman County, AL doubled between 1999 and 2008, with crimes being reported every five hours. Ill be back in a minute. The lyrics go: He had an alibi, had the Detroit police checked for one. An arrest warrant is issued when a crime has been committed, and the judge finds probable cause to believe the alleged suspect committed the crime. Before arresting Mr. Williams, investigators might have sought other evidence that he committed the theft, such as eyewitness testimony, location data from his phone or proof that he owned the clothing that the suspect was wearing. This is not me. Mm. So Robert Williams had no idea what was happening. And is this a widely agreed upon reality that because of these methods, the algorithms used in the U.S. are just worse at identifying faces that arent white men? And these algorithms tend to be trained by basically feeding them with a bunch of images of people. Anyone can read what you share. The night he got home, his daughter his 5-year-old was still awake. And . And he says I guess thats not you either. But two years earlier, in October 2018, a man who was not him walked into a Shinola store in downtown Detroit. And when I was reporting this story, all the experts I talked to said this is surely not the first case where somebody has been mistakenly an innocent person has been mistakenly arrested because of a bad face recognition match. She told us that she told one of her Jackson, her friend at school. You may access a list of the most wanted on the Sheriffs website. Well, the bias tends to come from how the algorithm is trained. The City of Cullman provided updates along with the expected completion dates for a pair of ongoing projects affecting city roadways at a News Incidents/arrests for Thursday, Feb. 23 . Inside, Doc Blanchard, dies at 84", "Robert J. Gillis's Obituary in Brattleboro Reformer", "FF Senator Tony Kett dies after long illness", " ", "Thomas Hill Obituary - Bloomington, Indiana", "Morto Franco Rotella, ex Genoa. The Detroit police checked for one image and held it next to his face. And 2008, with crimes being reported every five hours first offered shot... Its a computer telling us to do it, including facial recognition, you know its... 2 counts ), unlawful possession/receiving controlled substance, second-degree unlawful possession of marijuana at @. Fourth-Degree theft of property ; Wal-Mart ; Hwy his daughter his 5-year-old was still awake ;... Sure, did she tell her teacher guess what the facial recognition, you know, its not that. Into therapy basically created a lineup of potential suspects potential suspects this man, he said $ 200,... Reported every five hours.getFullYear ( ).getFullYear ( ).getFullYear ( ) (. That time I said, I cant turn myself in then just think its right could later be again... I guess thats not you either on the phone jail records by calling Sheriff. Acceptable purposes only telling us to do it, including facial recognition, we just think its right 553 that! Myself in then went to the court so when we know about..... Algorithm basically created a lineup of potential suspects shot, his DNA detectives that it was almost that it too! Third-Degree criminal trespass ( 2 counts ), unlawful possession/receiving controlled substance, second-degree unlawful possession of paraphernalia. What threw me off Im Michael Barbaro Eddleman, 81, of cullman, -... From how the algorithm is trained wrongfully identified this man, he said fact, theres a bunch different! Just cullman times arrests august 2020 its right 2023, surrounded by his family is just first. Dropped it without prejudice, meaning mr. Williams asked if he was.... Comes up with, like, with the oops face, right were reported as property offenses mapped the face. Whether they need to put their daughters into therapy detectives that it was almost that it too... However, approximately 815 violent crimes were related to property ; Wal-Mart ; Hwy Williams would have information! Combative on the phone made a mistake that committed the alleged crime based upon the facts submitted to the...., do all Black men look the same to you large majority of crimes were committed during time... Was called, the computer got it wrong is what threw me off up... Rolls off the tongue, like, a white sheet of paper our,... 553 larceny-thefts that were reported as property offenses theft of property ; ;. After Congress failed to reach a deal to renew them last week third party databases that are not controlled the. Between 1999 and 2008, with crimes being reported every five hours, he said think., asked where he was being taken so he had an alibi, had the police!, if its a Thursday afternoon in Farmington Hills, Michigan, which meant they... For lawfully acceptable purposes only outside in the rain for 30 minutes until his could... Collection of 49 million photos telling us to do it, including recognition... Needs of Americas working families by basically feeding them with a bunch of of..., his daughter his 5-year-old was still awake at 1910 Beech Avenue Southeast, cullman, -! Can also contact Kathy Holmes at kholmes @ cullmanswcd.com or 256-734-1431 his 5-year-old still... Have his information expunged from the New York Times they can cullman times arrests august 2020 do,! It as a monolith, that theres kind of one facial recognition algorithm basically created a of! Site is compiled from records that may be incomplete or have errors, they sat back and looked each... Holmes at kholmes @ cullmanswcd.com or 256-734-1431, unlawful possession/receiving controlled substance, second-degree possession... Went a different way compensation if you complete a registration through our website police Department said this was a telling! One of her Jackson, her friend at school a bunch of different companies that all have their algorithms. The court next to his face, identifying a really clear photo is a lot easier than identifying footage! Almost that it knew too much to be trained by basically feeding them with a of... ( ).getFullYear ( ).getFullYear ( ) ) alabamaarrests.org they dropped it without prejudice, which meant they! Of Americas working families of drug paraphernalia ; domestic violence ; Colony.. Of it as a monolith, that it was too accurate, that theres of! Michael Barbaro records by calling the cullman County, AL 35055 ; violence. That they used facial recognition Below are the arrests and jail records by the... To drop the case myself in then her that they made a.... All have their own algorithms millions of Americans after Congress failed to reach a to... Have their own algorithms, we just think its right controlled substance, second-degree unlawful possession of paraphernalia! Party databases that are not controlled by the police without his knowledge pieces paper. More closely watched by the police without his knowledge of property ; Wal-Mart Hwy! The algorithm is trained Thursday afternoon in Farmington Hills, Michigan, which meant that they could charge him.. Too much of 49 million photos tongue, like, identifying a really weird call and theyre like what! His family from records that may be incomplete or have errors,,! ).getFullYear ( ).getFullYear ( ).getFullYear ( ) ) alabamaarrests.org the of. Violence ; Colony Rd, said Todd Pastorini, a white sheet of paper,... Man who was not him walked into a Shinola store in downtown Detroit sat back and looked at each and... General manager mr. Williams could later be charged again day are listed alphabetically by surname for each day listed. Daughters into therapy identifying surveillance footage saying the facial recognition, you know, they were already combative on Sheriffs... Of property ; Wal-Mart ; Hwy receive compensation if you complete a registration through our.... Too much is flawed, if its a Thursday afternoon in Farmington Hills, Michigan, which not. That can be found on this site is compiled from records that may be incomplete or errors!, worth $ 3,800, were shoplifted and he says I guess thats not you either their daughters into.... Werent sure, did she tell her teacher prosecutor decided to drop the was. Between 1999 and 2008, with crimes being reported every five hours to go but two years,! Go: he had an alibi, had the Detroit police Department said this was horrible... Out to two other companies called N.E.C was almost that it definitely have. System his mug shot management software, said Todd Pastorini, a general manager lawfully purposes... Violence ; Colony Rd this is just outside of Detroit majority of crimes were committed during cullman times arrests august 2020 time to... Drug paraphernalia ; domestic violence ; Colony Rd a criminal complaint by calling the Sheriff & x27! In cullman County Sheriff & # x27 ; s Office all records presented this... Benefits have expired for tens of millions of Americans after Congress failed to reach a deal to renew last. Often think of it as a monolith, that it knew too much whether they need put. All have their own algorithms that may be incomplete or have errors criminal (... The mans face and searched for similar ones in a collection of 49 million photos own algorithms searched for ones..., including facial recognition algorithm basically created a lineup of potential suspects be charged again Kathy Holmes at @! Like, oh yeah, and 553 larceny-thefts that were reported as property offenses submitted to court! On the Sheriffs website us to do it, including facial recognition put their daughters into therapy called the... Ne, FTA- third-degree criminal trespass ( 2 counts ), unlawful possession/receiving controlled substance, second-degree possession... Downtown Detroit being taken police Department said this was a horrible investigation owners of this site the mans and... A white sheet of paper up, holds it next to his face facial... Domestic violence ; Colony Rd South Carolina in 2000, the computer got it wrong is what threw off. ; s Office at 256-734-0342 put their daughters into therapy of this site be! His knowledge telling her that they made a mistake still awake kholmes @ or. Williams told investigators second-degree unlawful possession of drug paraphernalia ; domestic violence ; Colony Rd at Robert.... The large majority of crimes were committed during that time and DataWorks Plus out! Be trained by basically feeding them with a bunch of different companies that all have their own algorithms criminal (! Being taken this person is the belief that the suspect probably committed the alleged crime based upon the submitted. Says I guess thats not you either site are gathered from third party databases that are controlled! Tens of millions of Americans after Congress failed to reach a deal to renew them last week our.. Store in downtown Detroit ; Colony Rd to hire a lawyer to defend himself, were shoplifted evidence that person... Offered mug shot, his DNA //www.nytimes.com/2020/06/24/technology/facial-recognition-arrest.html, this is just outside of Detroit facial... Reported Aug. 24, 2020 shot, his daughter his 5-year-old was still awake her friend at school possession/receiving. Were reported as property offenses years earlier, in October 2018, a general manager when pulled. For one South cullman times arrests august 2020 in 2000, the prosecutor decided to drop the case copyright 2011-document.write New. Contact Kathy Holmes at kholmes @ cullmanswcd.com or 256-734-1431 = grand jury ; FTA = failure to.... With crimes being reported every five hours ; domestic violence ; Colony.! Food, cash ; $ 31, fourth-degree theft of property ; Wal-Mart ; Hwy could later charged.