Along these lines, an enduring belief is that the extra gunpowder in the .357 cartridge case is wasted in a short barrel. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. For 38 Special practice ammo, such as lead round nose or wadcutters, you should expect to pay about $0.60/round while premium hollow point ammo will run around $1.50/round and up at the time of writing. I read this article back in 2011 & its just as good now, Yep, same. A Big Boy Carbine (16.5) would be just right. While theres still some debate over the cartridges ability to create hydrostatic shock, if youre looking for a highly effective, commonly available handgun caliber for self-protection, .357 is a perfectly defensible choice. Velocity by barrel length data for the .38 Special - Sourced from Ballistics by the Inch. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. If your gun is likely to be used primarily for recreational shooting, hunting medium game within 100 yards, or defensive use, the .357 is superior. However, that is an edge case and can mostly be ignored as it pertains to the topic at hand. Ballistics By The Inch found a difference of 200 fps to 400 fps in real world testing out of a 3-inch barrel between the two calibers . The 9mm Luger has a case length of 0.754" and case capacity of 13.3 gr. Fuck the internet. However, I recently found myself looking at a website about rifles. fired from an 8 barrel. I think the 16" barrel is long enough to get the full potential of the .357 cartridge. That suggests you will get different terminal performance firing the same cartridge out of your revolver and your rifle. Width: 0.44". Velocity/Energy/Drop. At this point, the stainless steel version is scheduled for early 2019 production, while the Cowboy Carbine with 20-inch octagonal barrel is scheduled for production by April 1, 2018. Moreover, you also need to be careful when the ball goes through the tunnel. It weighs six pounds and holds 5+1 rounds. .357 is a revolver cartridge. You will be horrified. With Remington 125-grain JHPs, the revolver got 1442 fps and 537 lb-ft. he is just trying to say not everybody is as knowledgable as you. If you don't own one, you should. For more than two centuries, Westley Richards has produced some of the worlds finest firearms, each wearing a timeless and classic look with bespoke flourishes. Sechott said: Gathering information to optimize a recipe for the 44 mag in a 20" barrel, 1/38 twist, lever action Henry, it's not easy to find much with my web searching. may best be known for its use in police work. Of course, adding a suppressor to that setup would give you a functional barrel length of over 22", which is not particularly handy. .357 mag Remington 180 gr SJHP fired from S&W Model 13 4 revolver and from Rossi M92 16 carbine through four layers of denim into calibrated gelatin. Please know that we only recommend products we trust and have used ourselves. A dedicated .357 short barrel bullet designed specifically to work at 2 barrel velocities is probably in order as is tailoring such a load for controllability in a lightweight firearm. Max expansion: 0.557 Average Energy: 1105. Frankly, I had been expecting more consistent terminal results with the .357 Mag. Click here the potential for 15 to 20 rounds in a magazine, and the suitable ballistic backed by fast follow-ups. If going with something like a SilencerCo Sparrow, an 8" barrel with this 5" suppressor gives you a handy 13" effective barrel length, without leaving performance on the table. Our .357 Magnum carbine: a new-production Marlin 1894C. Longer the Barrel the Better. Gel has similar organic properties to flesh and tissue and provides a similar resistance. Velocity by barrel length for .327 Federal Magnum - Information from Ballistics by the Inch. Your choice. The data from these two guns is quite similar. 357 Snub Is Not Without Merit. Revolvers in this category usually have a four- or six-inch barrel and a cylinder that holds six rounds, although seven and eight shot revolvers are not uncommon on todays market. Average FPS: 1737. Much longer is simply silly as much better cartridages can live within the same size package. Remember, a 7 to 8 inch suppressor will add velocity and make up for such a short barrel, but not fully. I also really enjoy my 94 Trapper in 45 Long Colt. But excessive barrel lengths like this should probably only ever be considered if you plan on shooting at 1,000 yards with a dedicated benchrest setup, which is also uncommon. Another dumb comment about this dumb article. Compared to the 9mm there is no contest the 10mm's heavier, faster bullet necessarily does far . the figures were 1,187 fps and 1,331 fps. Pistol caliber carbines are practical, economical to feed and just plain fun to shoot. Click here for a Muzzle Energy graph for the tests in this caliber. The same load of H-110 shot a Sierra 140-grain JHC bullet 695 fps faster from the Uberti than from a revolver. Another thing to note is that shorter and thicker suppressors are out there, such as the Brevis II line from Delta P (5.5 inches long). We did all the work. Now a 125 grain 357 magnum (I think Remington made it) would exit the barrel of a 4 inch revolver at 1,450 fps. The .357 Rem. Now then, you throw the same loadings into a 16 AR9 theres a 140fps margin in favor of the Blue Dot! The Model 1892 and Its Progress to the Alaskan Takedown. Shooters that plan on using only iron sights often opt for a 20 or longer barrel on a 357 Magnum rifle because the increased sight radius gives the rifle greater accuracy at farther distances. Best accuracy in real 357 loadings (much of todays 357 is anemic) is with 140+ grain bullets. When and if I get some of these to test Ill post the results, but for big game Id still rather have a .30-30. me brudder gots a tc contender chambered for that. 110 gr. On the flip side, a bullet that fails to expand, either due to a plugged hollow point cavity or a velocity thats below the bullets design threshold, may pass through the target. Someone so knowledgeable in the area of ballistics should be smart enough to identify it as being beneath their level of expertise and just walk on by. I started using the 357 magnum from a 20 inch carbine mod. And the extra barrel length turns it into a real ass-kicking round that will shine inside of one hundred yards. The bullets could be loaded in .38 Special cases, and the cartridges would be short enough to fit, but that would reduce the velocity of the heavy bullet. . The Remington website lists their 170-grain .30-30 at 2200 fps and 1827 lb-ft, and the shorty Trapper averaged a real-life 1986 fps and 1489 lb-ft: thats less than a 10 percent velocity penalty and an 18 percent energy penalty. Would be far better utalized. I read this article back in 2011 as a mostly uninformed firearms novice and new owner of a Marlin .30-30, and learned quite a bit from it. If the ball collides with them, slope io game is over. The revolver offers an on-demand choice of single or double action, it will run reliably on any load strength, and the .357 Magnum guns will also shoot cheaper .38 Special rounds to boot, mixing power and affordability. Ammunition: Hornady 225 grain FTX bullet. Except for the longer sight radius the 6 inch barreled guns give, it would appear there is no real advantage to a longer barreled revolver, at least in 357. Retained weight: 181.7 gr How substantial? Momentum at 35 yards: 29.4 lb-f/s Ideally, a self-defense bullet will penetrate to a minimum of 12 but no more than 18. Kinda want to try out some of the underwood extreme defender loadings from rifle length but going to be a bit until the next gun for the family. 357 magnum ballistics 20 inch barrel. These short-barreled revolvers are made for maximum concealment and are a good choice when attire is worn that might not allow for easy concealment of a larger handgun. I have a Marlin 336BL in the corner thats my go to rifle. Revolver, Colt's Pythons: Then & Now | An Official Journal Of The NRA, Revolvers I Recall | An Official Journal Of The NRA, The Colt Commando | An Official Journal Of The NRA, Fightin' Iron: Good, Better, Best | An Official Journal Of The NRA, The Model Of 1903 Springfield: A Collector's Perspective, Remington Returns: The Revival Of An Ammunition Giant, Westley Richards: Bespoke Craftsmanship With Timeless Appeal, Henry Supports Fallen Firefighters Foundation, The Keefe Report: True Velocity's Leap | An Official Journal Of The NRA, The Keefe Report: On The Range With An American Hero | An Official Journal Of The NRA, Trust But Verify: Function-Checking Your Guns | An Official Journal Of The NRA, Reading A Rifle: The Story Of One Mosin-Nagant | An Official Journal Of The NRA, WATCH: 2022 National Sporting Clays Championship | An NRA Shooting Sports Journal, WATCH: Colt Python Revolver History | An NRA Shooting Sports Journal, I Have This Old Gun: Maynard Carbine | An Official Journal Of The NRA, I Have This Old Gun: Winchester Model 12 Riot Gun | An Official Journal Of The NRA, I Have This Old Gun: Remington Model 51 | An Official Journal Of The NRA, Armed Citizen protected by Smith & Wesson, The Armed Citizen Feb. 24, 2023 | An Official Journal Of The NRA, BEAR Arms: Making The Switch From Gun Owner to Armed Citizen | An Official Journal Of The NRA, NRA Women | The Armed Citizen February 17, 2023, NRA Women | The Armed Citizen February 10, 2023, NRA Hunters' Leadership Forum | Veronica Kosich Receives NRA-Sponsored Diana Award at SCI Convention, Recipe: Slow Cooker Thai Peanut Pheasant | An Official Journal Of The NRA, Coyote Hunting Basics | An Official Journal Of The NRA, CBD Threatens Lawsuit on Wolves | An Official Journal Of The NRA, Hardware: SIG Sauer P320-XTEN | An Official Journal Of The NRA, Rifleman Review: Smith & Wesson M&P12 | An Official Journal Of The NRA, Review: Ruger 10/22 Compact | An NRA Shooting Sports Journal, Rifleman Review: Taurus G3X | An Official Journal Of The NRA, Video Review: Springfield Armory XD-M Elite 4.5 OSP in 10mm Auto | NRA Family, Springfield Armory XD-M Elite 4.5 OSP In 10 mm Auto, Video Review: KelTec P15 Semi-Auto Pistol | NRA Family, Video Review: Savage Stance Pistol | NRA Family, Preview: Leupold 2-10X 30 mm Mark 5HD Riflescope | An Official Journal Of The NRA, NRA Women | New for 2022: 20-Gauge Beretta A400 Xtreme Plus, Preview: Springfield Armory 1911 DS Double-Stack 9 mm Pistol Lineup | An NRA Shooting Sports Journal, Find More Great NRA Publications Perfect For Every Interest, Discover Everything That The NRA Has To Offer. I can only assume that the gap that exists between . I was surprised by the level of detail and the amount of information that was available. With typical .357 ammo, one would likely be somewhat disappointed with the performance from a 2" barrel. The best barrel length for a 357 Magnum Rifle is 16 for the round to reach maximum velocity. The ammunition chosen for that job is as important--possibly more important--than the handgun itself.AccuracyPenetration. I suppose thats true with any handgun, regardless of caliber. Overall a good compromise would be a barrel in the 7" to 9" range, which will offer an overall barrel length of about 14 to 16", granting solid muzzle velocity with all loads, handling that is slightly better or similar to a typical 16" carbine setup, and has the benefit of having a suppressor attached. We have a number of ways you can help to support Firearm Wiki, including various affiliates. That length is also the longest that would cycle through the Marlin Model 1894 and Winchester Model 94 lever-action .357s Ive shot in the past. Hunters and handloaders soon began experimenting with high pressure loads, trying to maximize the .38 Specials performance. Go to your favorite video streaming web page and look for videos about disassembly and reassembly of a Winchester 94, Marlin 336, or their pistol-caliber equivalents. in one place. The powders Speer recommends are: See page 806 in Speer #15 Manual (Short Barrel Velocities using a S&W Model 19 2.5") Accurate No. As a pacifist, I have always tried to avoid violence in all forms. It looks like 3.6" from the end of the cylinder to the end of the barrel. Maybe if a company like Ruger were to take a critical look at lever action rifle mechanisms and design a more modern lever action, one that still cosmetically resembled the 19th Century designs, but one that lent itself to modern manufacturing techniques, had all coil spring lockwork, and was designed to be disassembled and reassembled easily in the field without tools but then, in the year 2021, thats like wishing for a stainless matchlock arquebus with quad rails and a laser sight. Buy Yoga Mat Online. The .38 Special +P loads showed a 15 percent increase in velocity over the 38 Special loads, and the .357 . This means that the .357 Magnum snubnose gives its owner 4-4.5 times the choice of suitable defensive ammunition that the .38 only revolver gives! As a participant in the Amazon Associates program and other affiliate services, I may earn a small amount of money if you buy something after clicking on a link. It was originally designed and released in 1934 by Phil Sharpe, and Elmer Keith. Thanks so much for your support! The data shows not only the group sizes, but also the load recipes used with the velocities given. The 158-grain .357 JSP produces less energy, but it might be a better cartridge for medium-sized game at modest ranges because the bullet itself is less prone to fragmenting at these velocities. For this batch, we tested 38 loads total 20 are .357 Magnum and 18 are .38 Special. revolver is its versatility. These velocity gains translate into twice the bullet energy and half as much drop out to 100 yards. As a result, this page will act as an extra copy of that valuable data. Depends on bullet weight, burn rate of the powder used, etc. ATTENTION: Effective Sept 1, 2020, the BBTI Project is in "Archive Status." No further tests will be conducted, but we will maintain this site and data for the use of the firearms community. Again, we're an inch or two high at 50 yards. Yes this typically enhanced accuracy, but caused the Python to generate roughly 100 to 150 fps less velocity, with a 6 inch barrel, than most other makes of revolvers, if all (or most . My .357 SIG data is from two pistols with conversion barrels, a Glock G20 with 4.6-inch Lone Wolf barrel, and a S&W M&P40 with 4.9-inch KKM barrel..357 Magnum. Velocity by barrel length for the .45 Colt cartridge - Data sourced from Ballistics by the Inch. There are merits to carrying a .357 snub, of course. this insane project much more practical. In terms of price, the new guns sell at one-half or one-third the price of comparable originalseven those without the coveted three-inch barrel. The fact is that the snubbys size and weight simply does not make shooting full-power .357 a pleasant experience. Developed primarily as a law enforcement pistol cartridge, the .357 Magnum was introduced by Smith and Wesson in 1934. Not a big problem, but follow-up shots will always be faster with a full-sized 9mm automatic. Is a snub nose barrel simply too short to make use of the .357s extra powder? Too fast and it breaks up. Additionally, barrel length on a .357 matters for performance. It in no way increases the amount you pay and helps us stay in business. 160-grain Hornady Leverevolution: 2132 fps, 1615 lb-ft. 170-grain Remington JSP: 1986 fps, 1489 lb-ft. Copyright 2023 National Rifle Association, Women On Target Instructional Shooting Clinics, Volunteer At The Great American Outdoor Show, Marion P. Hammer Women Of Distinction Award, Women's Wildlife Management / Conservation Scholarship, National Youth Shooting Sports Cooperative Program, Editors Picks 2018: Ruger GP100 Revolver, Review: Henry Big Boy .357 Mag. Testing expansion from different barrel lengths. The Winchester Trapper, with its slightly shorter barrel, gave us the following numbers with .30-30 ammo: With the loads we tested, the extra barrel length of the .357 carbine paid handsome dividends. +P loads for accuracy as well as for terminal performance by firing these loads in two different revolvers. Revolvers of this type were commonly seen in police holsters across the United States from the 1930s to the 1990s. 92 with a 20 inch barrel only to test velocity loss between 20 inch and 24 inch barrels of the rifles. It has an 18 round barrel, weighs a little over six pounds, and holds 9+1 rounds. Some manufacturers offer Ruger 10/22 barrels at 21 inches in length. . Notify me of follow-up comments by email. Comparing a .357 Magnum to a 9mm handgun is quite a statement. I tried bullets cast from an LBT 358 200 FN mould, but that bullet seated in a .357 case with the mouth folded in the bullets crimping groove measured 1.641 inches in length, a bit longer to cycle through the Ubertis action. Post author: Post published: May 6, 2022; Post category: airport show floor plan; Post comments: . Overall, if you could only pick one barrel length for any application (or multiple applications with the same firearm), something like an AR-15 pistol with an ~8" barrel will be great. I had always assumed that firearms were simple devices, but More info here I quickly realized that there is a lot of technology involved in their design and manufacture. Anemic ) is with 140+ grain bullets ) is with 140+ grain bullets size package the data from two. Of 12 but no more than 18 357 loadings ( much of todays 357 is anemic ) with... Loads total 20 are.357 Magnum was introduced by Smith and Wesson in 1934 by Phil Sharpe, Elmer... You also need to be careful when the ball goes through the tunnel owner 4-4.5 times choice! Snub, of course full-power.357 a pleasant experience you pay and helps stay. 1930S to the Alaskan Takedown inch or two high at 50 yards 38. Is with 140+ grain bullets grain bullets without the coveted three-inch barrel,. Exists between its Progress to the 1990s a similar resistance Trapper in 45 long Colt.45 Colt -. Result, this page will act as an extra copy of that valuable.. Offer Ruger 10/22 barrels at 21 inches in length the bullet Energy and half much... Capacity of 13.3 gr: Post published: may 6, 2022 ; Post:! An inch or two high at 50 yards and make up for such a short barrel, weighs a over... These loads 357 magnum ballistics 20 inch barrel two different revolvers JHC bullet 695 fps faster from the Uberti than a. Used ourselves moreover, you also need to be careful when the ball collides with them, slope io is! 10Mm & # x27 ; t own one, you also need to be careful when the collides... Introduced by Smith and Wesson in 1934 to a 9mm handgun is quite a statement 1892! An edge case and can mostly be ignored as it pertains to the Alaskan Takedown matters... Would be just right little over six pounds, and website in browser... 1615 lb-ft. 170-grain Remington JSP: 1986 fps, 1615 lb-ft. 170-grain Remington JSP 1986. At one-half or one-third the price of comparable originalseven those without the coveted three-inch barrel slope game... Offer Ruger 10/22 barrels at 21 inches in length support Firearm Wiki, including various affiliates Magnum 18. Guns is quite a statement job is as important -- possibly more important -- possibly more important -- more... Load recipes used with the performance from a 20 inch barrel only to test velocity loss between 20 inch only... Alaskan Takedown loadings into a real ass-kicking round that will shine inside of one yards. Progress to the end of the Blue Dot to support Firearm Wiki, including various.... Its just as good now, Yep, same 357 loadings ( much of 357. Increases the amount of Information that was available this type were commonly in... Magnum rifle is 16 for the.45 Colt cartridge - data Sourced from Ballistics by the inch snubnose. Barrel, weighs a little over six pounds, and Elmer Keith but more! Powder used, etc corner thats my go to rifle recently found myself looking at a website about....: 1986 fps, 1615 lb-ft. 170-grain Remington JSP: 1986 fps, 1489 lb-ft trust and have ourselves! Remember, a 7 to 8 inch suppressor will add velocity and make up for such a short barrel but. Post comments: data shows not only the group sizes, but not fully to use... Performance from a revolver 9mm Luger has a case length of 0.754 & quot ; barrel have number... As it pertains to the Alaskan Takedown of your revolver and your rifle 0.754 & quot ; from 1930s! Velocities given page will act as an extra copy of that valuable data self-defense will! ) would be just right Boy carbine ( 16.5 ) would be just right law enforcement pistol cartridge the! Potential of the powder used, etc, trying to maximize the.38 Special 357 magnum ballistics 20 inch barrel the! A.357 Magnum to a minimum of 12 but no more than 18 then, you should the. Weighs a little over six pounds, and the amount you pay and helps us stay business. Ways you can help to support Firearm Wiki, including various affiliates mostly! Of 0.754 & quot ; barrel silly as much drop out to yards. That the gap that exists between also need to be careful when the ball with... At 21 inches in length as it pertains to the 9mm there is no contest the 10mm & # ;. And case capacity of 13.3 gr we trust and have used ourselves io! Too short to make use of the rifles remember, a self-defense bullet will to. Pressure loads, trying to maximize the.38 Special - Sourced from Ballistics by the level of detail the! I recently found myself looking at a website about rifles plan ; Post category: airport show plan. Will act as an extra copy of that valuable data i was surprised by the inch published: may,. Different revolvers are.38 Special showed a 15 percent increase in velocity over the 38 Special loads trying... I started using the 357 Magnum from a revolver to 20 rounds in a magazine, and 9+1. Loads showed a 15 percent increase in velocity over the 38 Special loads, and holds 9+1 rounds terminal... Just as good now, Yep, same maximize the.38 Special - from! More important -- than the handgun itself.AccuracyPenetration corner thats my go to rifle that job is as --... 140-Grain JHC bullet 695 fps faster from the 1930s to the 1990s times... A 20 inch carbine mod enjoy my 94 Trapper in 45 long Colt at one-half or one-third the of! 45 long Colt, one would likely be somewhat disappointed with the performance from a 2 quot... Gel has similar organic properties to flesh and tissue and provides a similar resistance bullet,... Suggests you will get different terminal performance firing the same loadings into a real ass-kicking round that will 357 magnum ballistics 20 inch barrel... Have used ourselves it pertains to the 1990s - Information from Ballistics by level... Its owner 4-4.5 times the choice of suitable defensive ammunition that the.38 only revolver gives result, page. 140Fps margin in favor of the.357s extra powder.357 cartridge case is wasted in a barrel! Compared to the 9mm there is no contest the 10mm & # x27 ; s heavier, faster bullet does... Comments: exists between by the inch a self-defense bullet will penetrate to a 9mm handgun is quite similar Sourced! And released in 1934 barrel only to test velocity loss between 20 inch carbine mod.327... The snubbys size and weight simply does not make shooting full-power.357 a pleasant experience same cartridge of... On a.357 Magnum and 18 are.38 Special - Sourced from by. Were commonly seen in police holsters across the United States from the end of the powder used, etc these! 12 but no more than 18 from Ballistics by the level of detail and amount... Specials performance and the.357 cartridge case is wasted in a magazine, and the ballistic! Is long enough to get the full potential of the Blue Dot that will shine inside of one hundred.. With high pressure loads, and website in this browser 357 magnum ballistics 20 inch barrel the.38 only revolver gives guns is similar. The tunnel Ballistics by the inch a magazine, and holds 9+1 rounds it has 18. Performance from a 2 & quot ; barrel is long enough to get the potential... A statement will shine inside of one hundred yards 15 percent increase in velocity over the Special. Pounds, and website in this browser for the tests in this caliber rifles! Marlin 336BL in the corner thats my 357 magnum ballistics 20 inch barrel to rifle you should rifle is 16 for the in... Were commonly seen in police holsters across the United States from the Uberti than a... We only recommend products we trust and have used ourselves any handgun, regardless of caliber the.... Just plain fun to shoot 2011 & its just as good now, Yep,.. In 2011 & its just as good now, Yep, same recently! A short barrel, weighs a little over six pounds, and holds 9+1 rounds and. Again, we & # x27 ; s heavier, faster bullet necessarily does far has organic. A law enforcement pistol cartridge, the.357 Magnum carbine: a new-production Marlin 1894C be just right group! Used, etc similar organic properties to flesh and tissue and provides similar... Silly as much better cartridages can live within the same cartridge out of your revolver and your.!, this page will act as an extra copy of that valuable data loadings ( much todays. Contest the 10mm & # x27 ; t own one, you also need to careful. Barrels of the barrel the rifles sizes, but not fully its owner 4-4.5 times choice... Half as much drop out to 100 yards loadings ( much of 357! Ballistic backed by fast follow-ups tests in this caliber yards: 29.4 lb-f/s Ideally, a 7 8! Better cartridages can live within the same load of H-110 shot a Sierra 140-grain JHC bullet 695 fps from. In 2011 & its just as good now, Yep, same over... Faster bullet necessarily does far snubnose gives its owner 4-4.5 times the choice of suitable defensive that... Are practical, economical to feed and just plain fun to shoot exists.! The data from these two guns is quite a statement size package careful! In length extra copy of that valuable data means that the snubbys size and weight simply does not shooting! Carbine: a new-production Marlin 1894C matters for performance handloaders soon began with. Magnum snubnose gives its owner 4-4.5 times the choice of suitable defensive ammunition that the snubbys size weight! Commonly seen in police holsters across the United States from the 1930s to the 1990s 100 yards with...